Comments on: Part 2 – Gobbledegook and regurgitation in the written judgments of the Court of Appeal in Zambry v Nizar: Postscript – Zainun Ali JCA’s judgment http://loyarburok.com/the-system/judging-the-judges-the-system/part-2-gobbledegook-and-regurgitation-in-the-written-judgments-of-the-court-of-appeal-in-zambry-v-nizar-postscript-zainun-ali-jcas-judgment/ Tue, 16 Mar 2010 15:50:20 -0500 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.6 hourly 1 By: Lawyer Lua http://loyarburok.com/the-system/judging-the-judges-the-system/part-2-gobbledegook-and-regurgitation-in-the-written-judgments-of-the-court-of-appeal-in-zambry-v-nizar-postscript-zainun-ali-jcas-judgment/comment-page-1/#comment-2962 Lawyer Lua Sat, 11 Jul 2009 06:00:55 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3511#comment-2962 We all know the real cause. But we also have the duty to ensure that the confidence in the Judiciary is not destroyed. The Common Judge is the foundation of a civilised society.The Rule in Politics is self-preservation; but the Rule in Law is without-self. We all know the real cause. But we also have the duty to ensure that the confidence in the Judiciary is not destroyed. The Common Judge is the foundation of a civilised society.The Rule in Politics is self-preservation; but the Rule in Law is without-self.

]]> By: telur dua http://loyarburok.com/the-system/judging-the-judges-the-system/part-2-gobbledegook-and-regurgitation-in-the-written-judgments-of-the-court-of-appeal-in-zambry-v-nizar-postscript-zainun-ali-jcas-judgment/comment-page-1/#comment-2961 telur dua Sat, 11 Jul 2009 05:33:03 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3511#comment-2961 I remember my school days when we were given a title on which we write an essay. My classmate wrote a nice long one but got 0 marks. He wrote out of point. Judges like those above should be given 0 marks as well. I remember my school days when we were given a title on which we write an essay.

My classmate wrote a nice long one but got 0 marks. He wrote out of point.

Judges like those above should be given 0 marks as well.

]]> By: shafeek taff http://loyarburok.com/the-system/judging-the-judges-the-system/part-2-gobbledegook-and-regurgitation-in-the-written-judgments-of-the-court-of-appeal-in-zambry-v-nizar-postscript-zainun-ali-jcas-judgment/comment-page-1/#comment-2960 shafeek taff Sat, 11 Jul 2009 05:12:54 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3511#comment-2960 Dear Saudara Chan, You give meaning and substance to the title of address (for want of a better phrase)- "Your Honour" which apparently the three stooges who sat on this case could not. They do not exhibit nor understand the concept of this appellation (?)as they in their person have no honour. Unfortunately, the Malaysian Judiciary is slowly(?) being populated by such men and women whose integrity, intelligence and courage are questionable. I want to say God save us, but since I do not believe in the existence of God or Santa Clause or even fairies at the bottom of the garden, we, the citizens of this country will have to do something to save our beautiful country. Dear Saudara Chan,
You give meaning and substance to the title of address (for want of a better phrase)- “Your Honour” which apparently the three stooges who sat on this case could not. They do not exhibit nor understand the concept of this appellation (?)as they in their person have no honour.
Unfortunately, the Malaysian Judiciary is slowly(?) being populated by such men and women whose integrity, intelligence and courage are questionable.
I want to say God save us, but since I do not believe in the existence of God or Santa Clause or even fairies at the bottom of the garden, we, the citizens of this country will have to do something to save our beautiful country.

]]> By: you better believe it! http://loyarburok.com/the-system/judging-the-judges-the-system/part-2-gobbledegook-and-regurgitation-in-the-written-judgments-of-the-court-of-appeal-in-zambry-v-nizar-postscript-zainun-ali-jcas-judgment/comment-page-1/#comment-2959 you better believe it! Sat, 11 Jul 2009 04:53:14 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3511#comment-2959 If these Kangaroo judges do not lean towards their political masters, how are they going to be promoted?...especially with their sub par ability and knowlege of their profession. Obviously, Malaysia is not short of talents but, this is not the objective and motive of this corrupted UMNO-BN scumbag gomen! They use 'holy cows' to clinch on to power!!! If these Kangaroo judges do not lean towards their political masters, how are they going to be promoted?…especially with their sub par ability and knowlege of their profession.
Obviously, Malaysia is not short of talents but, this is not the objective and motive of this corrupted UMNO-BN scumbag gomen! They use ‘holy cows’ to clinch on to power!!!

]]> By: aca http://loyarburok.com/the-system/judging-the-judges-the-system/part-2-gobbledegook-and-regurgitation-in-the-written-judgments-of-the-court-of-appeal-in-zambry-v-nizar-postscript-zainun-ali-jcas-judgment/comment-page-1/#comment-2956 aca Sat, 11 Jul 2009 04:31:22 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3511#comment-2956 in the best interest of his subject? funny, isnt it public knowledge that the best interest for the subject is to dissolve the assembly and let the subject decides for themselves the govt they want? who dares to place trust anymore in the judiciary who makes decision contrary to the Constitution? Dare to engage in biz with BN cronies and let your disputes, if any, decide by this batch of apex court judges? I wish you good luck. in the best interest of his subject?

funny, isnt it public knowledge that the best interest for the subject is to dissolve the assembly and let the subject decides for themselves the govt they want?

who dares to place trust anymore in the judiciary who makes decision contrary to the Constitution? Dare to engage in biz with BN cronies and let your disputes, if any, decide by this batch of apex court judges? I wish you good luck.

]]> By: S.Y. http://loyarburok.com/the-system/judging-the-judges-the-system/part-2-gobbledegook-and-regurgitation-in-the-written-judgments-of-the-court-of-appeal-in-zambry-v-nizar-postscript-zainun-ali-jcas-judgment/comment-page-1/#comment-2954 S.Y. Sat, 11 Jul 2009 04:10:13 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3511#comment-2954 Dear NH Chan, Please do not stop to point out the wrong and enlighten us, the public Dear NH Chan,

Please do not stop to point out the wrong and enlighten us, the public

]]> By: MatTop http://loyarburok.com/the-system/judging-the-judges-the-system/part-2-gobbledegook-and-regurgitation-in-the-written-judgments-of-the-court-of-appeal-in-zambry-v-nizar-postscript-zainun-ali-jcas-judgment/comment-page-1/#comment-2940 MatTop Fri, 10 Jul 2009 15:06:48 +0000 http://loyarburok.com/?p=3511#comment-2940 'Gobbledegook' and 'balderbash' are the words used to describe the CA of Appeal judgements. These are strong words and what it really mean in plain language is that those judgements are pure and complete nonsense. The judges' attitude in hearing the appeal is this: "We decide first and overule the High Crt judgement so that Zambery could regain the MBship. The reasons for our judgement we will think about it later". ‘Gobbledegook’ and ‘balderbash’ are the words used to describe the CA of Appeal judgements. These are strong words and what it really mean in plain language is that those judgements are pure and complete nonsense.

The judges’ attitude in hearing the appeal is this: “We decide first and overule the High Crt judgement so that Zambery could regain the MBship. The reasons for our judgement we will think about it later”.

]]>